Are You in the Market for an Ion Chromatography System?

By

Ion chromatography (IC) is an instrumental technique used extensively in the environmental, pharmaceutical, life sciences, biotechnology, chemical, petrochemical, food and beverage, power generation, and electronics industries. Applications include anion and cations, carbohydrates, organic acids, amino acids, proteins, peptides, oligonucleotides, oxyhalides, carboxylates, polysaccharides, polyphosphates, fatty acids, metals, phenols, surfactants, and ethanolamines.

As IC continues to develop, the number of ion-exchange materials developed for IC has increased, facilitated by the understanding of the process taking place at the surface of the stationary phase.

As IC continues to develop, the number of ion-exchange materials developed for IC has increased, facilitated by the understanding of the process taking place at the surface of the stationary phase.

Depending on the separation mode (ion exchange, ion exclusion or ion pair), different types of stationary phases are used.

Ion-Exchange Chromatography–is used for the separation of both inorganic and organic anions and cations.

Ion-Exclusion Chromatography –is used for the separation of weak inorganic and organic acids from completely dissociated acids that elute as one peak within the void volume of the column. In combination with suitable detection systems, this separation method is also useful for determining amino acids, aldehydes, and alcohols.

Ion-Pair Chromatography –is used for the separation of surface-active anions and cations, sulfur compounds, amines, and transition metal complexes.

Separation method for the ion chromatography system respondents are currently using or planning to use:

Chemical suppression detection 33%
Electrolytic suppression detection 19%
Ion suppression chromatography 39%
Electronic suppression detection 7%
Other 2%

Ion chromatography instruments closely resemble conventional HPLC, where typical components include an autosampler, a high pressure pump, an injection valve with a sample loop of suitable size, a guard column, an analytical column, a flow-through detector, and a data system, which can be of varying complexity.

Respondents selected the following components with their ion chromatography system.

Chromatography software 40%
Automatic sampler 30%
Chemical suppressor 21%
Automatic dilution/filtration/dialysis 9%

With a sensitive technique such as IC, the effects of contamination have serious consequences, with the potential to negate experimental results. The effects of contamination from ions, organics, colloids, bacteria, and gases can all impact sensitivity and reproducibility to some degree. Contaminating ions tend to have a significant but short-term effect, producing high blanks, high background, and chemical interferences that directly degrade results and reduce sensitivity. Varying levels of contaminating ions would result in higher variances in the observed results. While organics, colloids, and bacteria will also affect background/ blanks, they also tend to have a long-term impact through media fouling and surface coating that can affect parts of the instrumentation, such as the chromatography column, the detector, or inner surfaces of the system itself. The net effect of this type of fouling is anomalous baseline shifts, unknown peaks on the baseline, high noise etc.

When choosing a laboratory water purification system for analytical applications such as IC, it is essential to consider systems that combine such technologies and incorporate realtime monitoring of water purity in order to have confidence in the water and confidence in the experimental results.

According to the respondents, ionic and organic are the most common types of contaminants experienced in their IC applications.

Ionic 29%
Organic 23%
Particulate 11%
Strong acid or base 10%
Bacterial 4%
Gaseous 4%
Don’t know 8%
Other 1%

Dionex is the marketshare leader in IC, but there are a few other choices to consider – Metrohm, Waters, Shimadzu, Cecil Instruments, and Bio-Rad. The most important consideration in the purchase of an IC is making sure that the system you are looking at has a proven track record for the analysis you want to do.

IC systems offer a number of advantages that are important to respondents in their purchasing process: quality of data, speed, sensitivity, and increased lab throughput. With the introduction of high efficiency separator columns for ion-exchange, ion-exclusion, and ion-pair chromatography, the average analysis time could be reduced. Therefore, quantitative results are obtained in a fraction of the time previously required for traditional wet-chemical methods, thus increasing the sample throughput.

Top 12 features/factors that influence the buying decision

Accuracy/Quality of data 94%
Sensitivity 89%
Speed 85%
Ease of maintenance 85%
Increase lab throughput 83%
Resolution 83%
Service and support 79%
Safety 72%
Warranties 72%
Easy transfer of methods 70%
Price 70%
Training 70%

Completed Surveys: 173

For more information on Ion Chromatography, visit www.labmanager.com/IC

Categories: Surveys

Published In

Top 10 Management Skills You Need Magazine Issue Cover
Top 10 Management Skills You Need

Published: October 1, 2011

Cover Story

Top 10 Management Skills You Need

To progress in their careers, lab managers, particularly those in their first management assignment, need to develop new skills. Often they had little opportunity to do this while working full time at the laboratory bench. Yet these skills are critical to success in their new management assignment.