What Is the Tully Monster?
The Tully Monster (Tullimonstrum gregarium) is one of the most puzzling fossil discoveries in history. Dating back 300 million years, this ancient marine creature has defied classification since its discovery in the 1950s. Unlike typical fossils of hard-shelled creatures or bones, the Tully Monster was soft-bodied, making its preservation rare and its classification difficult.
First discovered by fossil hunter Francis Tully at Mazon Creek Lagerstätte, Illinois, this creature has intrigued scientists for decades. Measuring around 15 centimeters (6 inches) in length, it had an elongated body, a proboscis-like organ with teeth, and eye stalks positioned laterally—features that make it unlike any known modern organism.
Lab Quality Management Certificate
The Lab Quality Management certificate is more than training—it’s a professional advantage.
Gain critical skills and IACET-approved CEUs that make a measurable difference.
The Debate: Vertebrate or Invertebrate?
For years, researchers have debated whether the Tully Monster was a vertebrate (an animal with a backbone) or an invertebrate (an animal without a backbone). In 2016, a group of scientists proposed that the Tully Monster was a vertebrate related to jawless fish like lampreys and hagfish (McCoy et al., 2016). If true, this would have made the Tully Monster a key piece in understanding vertebrate evolution. However, this hypothesis remained controversial, with conflicting studies supporting and rejecting the claim.
The New Research: 3D Imaging Reveals Key Insights
A team from the University of Tokyo and Nagoya University has now provided compelling 3D imaging evidence suggesting that the Tully Monster was not a vertebrate. Using advanced scanning technologies, they examined over 150 Tully Monster fossils and more than 70 other fossilized animals from Mazon Creek.
"We believe that the mystery of it being an invertebrate or vertebrate has been solved," said Tomoyuki Mikami, a researcher at the National Museum of Nature and Science.
Key Findings from the Study
Segmented Head Structure – The study found that the Tully Monster had head segmentation that extended from its body, a trait not found in any known vertebrate lineage.
X-ray Micro-Computed Tomography (Micro-CT Scanning) – The scans of its proboscis and internal structures showed inconsistencies with vertebrate features, refuting the hypothesis that it was a primitive jawless fish.
3D Laser Scanning for Surface Mapping – Color-coded 3D mapping revealed details in fossilized specimens that had not been visible before, helping to clarify its anatomical features.
These findings strongly indicate that the Tully Monster was an invertebrate, though its exact classification remains unresolved.
What Type of Invertebrate Was the Tully Monster?
Although researchers now believe the Tully Monster was not a vertebrate, the question remains: what kind of invertebrate was it? Scientists have proposed two possibilities:
A Nonvertebrate Chordate – This means the Tully Monster may have been related to lancelets, small, fish-like marine animals that share some characteristics with vertebrates.
A Protostome with Radically Modified Morphology – Protostomes are a diverse group that includes insects, roundworms, earthworms, and mollusks. Some scientists speculate that the Tully Monster could belong to this group but with unusual evolutionary adaptations.
The Importance of Mazon Creek Fossils
The Mazon Creek Lagerstätte, where the Tully Monster was discovered, is one of the world’s most significant fossil sites for preserving soft-bodied organisms. The exceptional conditions of this site allowed delicate creatures like the Tully Monster to be fossilized in fine detail, providing rare insights into ancient marine ecosystems.
"There were many interesting animals that were never preserved as fossils," said Mikami. "Research on Mazon Creek fossils provides paleontological evidence that cannot be obtained from other sites."
Studying these fossils helps scientists piece together the evolutionary history of life, uncovering creatures that may have played critical roles in ancient ecosystems.
Why Does the Tully Monster Matter?
Understanding the Tully Monster’s classification is more than just solving an ancient puzzle—it provides key insights into how life evolved on Earth. If it were a vertebrate, it could have filled an important gap in early vertebrate evolution. However, as an invertebrate, it challenges scientists to reconsider what we know about marine life millions of years ago.
Future Research Directions
While researchers now have strong evidence that the Tully Monster was not a vertebrate, further research is needed to determine its exact classification. Future studies may explore:
- Comparative analysis with modern invertebrates to identify similarities.
- Further fossil discoveries at Mazon Creek to find more well-preserved specimens.
- Advanced genetic and chemical analysis of fossilized tissue, if possible.
Conclusion
The Tully Monster remains one of the most mysterious creatures in the fossil record. Although recent 3D imaging studies suggest it was an invertebrate, scientists are still working to understand exactly where it fits in the tree of life. This discovery highlights the importance of ongoing paleontological research, as each new fossil finding has the potential to reshape our understanding of Earth’s history.
As technology advances, future studies may finally unlock the secrets of the Tully Monster, providing a clearer picture of the ancient marine world it once inhabited.
This content includes text that has been generated with the assistance of AI. Lab Manager’s AI policy can be found here.
