Thermal analysis plays a critical role in material characterization across numerous industries, from pharmaceuticals to polymers and composites. These techniques help scientists understand how materials respond to changes in temperature, uncovering critical information related to thermal stability, phase transitions, composition, and performance properties. Accurate thermal characterization is essential for quality control, product development, failure analysis, and regulatory compliance in fields such as pharmaceuticals, plastics, food, energy storage, and advanced materials.

Two of the most widely used thermal analysis techniques are Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA) and Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC). Each technique offers unique and complementary insights into thermal properties. TGA focuses on mass changes, revealing decomposition, moisture content, and thermal stability, while DSC measures heat flow, providing data on phase transitions, melting, crystallization, and heat capacity.

Get training in Asset Management and earn CEUs.

One of over 25 IACET-accredited courses in the Academy.

Asset Management course

Understanding the differences between TGA and DSC, as well as how they can work together, allows laboratories to choose the most appropriate analytical approach for specific materials and applications.

This guide compares TGA vs DSC, examining how they work, what they measure, their applications, and key factors to consider when choosing between these complementary techniques.

What is Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA)?

Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA) is a powerful analytical technique used to measure the change in mass of a sample as it undergoes controlled heating, cooling, or is held at a constant temperature. This technique is crucial for understanding the thermal stability and composition of materials across a range of industries. By tracking weight loss (or gain) as a function of temperature or time, TGA can reveal decomposition points, moisture content, oxidative stability, and overall material composition, making it indispensable in quality control, research, and product development.

How TGA Works

In a typical TGA experiment, a small sample is placed in a crucible or pan suspended on a highly sensitive microbalance within a temperature-controlled furnace. The sample is subjected to a precisely controlled temperature program, often involving heating at a constant rate. The balance continuously monitors the sample's mass while the furnace heats or cools the sample. Inert gases like nitrogen or reactive gases like oxygen can be introduced to modify the atmosphere, allowing the user to study oxidative degradation, thermal decomposition, or even combustion processes. Advanced TGA systems can also be coupled with spectroscopic techniques such as FTIR or mass spectrometry (MS) to analyze gases evolved during thermal decomposition, providing even deeper insights into sample composition.

What TGA Measures

• Decomposition temperatures
• Moisture or solvent content
• Oxidative stability
• Thermal degradation profiles
• Composition analysis (e.g., polymer content, fillers, and residuals)

What is Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC)?

Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) is a fundamental technique in thermal analysis that measures the heat flow into or out of a sample as its temperature is increased, decreased, or held constant. By capturing the heat absorbed or released during thermal events, DSC provides critical insight into a material's phase transitions and thermal behavior. This technique is especially useful for studying melting, crystallization, glass transitions, curing reactions, and heat capacities across a wide variety of materials, from polymers and pharmaceuticals to foods and metals.

How DSC Works

In a DSC experiment, both the sample and a chemically inert reference material are placed into identical pans, housed within the DSC instrument. These pans are heated simultaneously at a precisely controlled rate. The DSC instrument continuously monitors the difference in heat flow between the sample and the reference. When the sample undergoes a thermal event—such as melting, crystallization, or a phase transition—the heat flow changes, creating peaks or shifts in the thermogram. These heat flow changes are directly proportional to the thermal events occurring within the sample, allowing for accurate determination of transition temperatures, enthalpies, and heat capacities. Advanced DSC systems can also operate under different atmospheric conditions (nitrogen, oxygen, etc.), making it possible to study oxidation reactions, decomposition, and other specialized thermal processes.

What DSC Measures

• Melting and crystallization points
• Glass transition temperatures
• Enthalpy changes (heat capacity)
• Curing reactions
• Phase transitions

TGA vs DSC: Side-by-Side Comparison

Applications of TGA and DSC in Different Industries

Pharmaceuticals

Thermal analysis is essential in the pharmaceutical industry for ensuring the stability and efficacy of drug products. TGA and DSC are used to analyze both active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) and excipients, helping to assess their thermal behavior under different conditions.

• TGA: Determines thermal stability, moisture content, and decomposition profiles of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) and excipients.
• DSC: Measures melting points, polymorphic transitions, and crystallinity.

Polymers and Plastics

The development and quality control of polymers and plastics require detailed thermal profiling. TGA and DSC play complementary roles in characterizing the thermal properties of polymers, including degradation behavior, phase transitions, and crystallinity.

• TGA: Analyzes polymer degradation, filler content, and composition.
• DSC: Characterizes glass transitions, melting behavior, and crystallinity.

Food and Agriculture

In the food and agriculture industries, thermal analysis helps understand ingredient behavior, product stability, and processing characteristics. Both TGA and DSC are used to evaluate moisture content, phase transitions, and thermal degradation.

• TGA: Quantifies moisture and ash content.
• DSC: Studies melting profiles, ingredient compatibility, and fat crystallization.

Energy and Environment

The energy and environmental sectors rely on thermal analysis to evaluate the properties of fuels, waste materials, and sustainable energy components. Both TGA and DSC provide crucial data for understanding combustion, decomposition, and phase behavior.

• TGA: Evaluates thermal decomposition of biomass, waste, and alternative fuels.
• DSC: Analyzes phase transitions in battery materials and polymers for renewable energy applications.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between TGA and DSC

1. Measurement Goals

Choosing between TGA and DSC depends largely on the primary goals of your thermal analysis. Consider whether your focus is on understanding the thermal stability and decomposition profile of a material, or on detecting and characterizing phase transitions.

• If you need to understand thermal stability and composition, TGA is the better choice.
• If you are more focused on phase transitions and heat flow, DSC is the preferred technique.

2. Sample Type

The nature and composition of your sample play a key role in selecting the appropriate thermal analysis technique. Both TGA and DSC are highly versatile, but they excel with different types of materials.

• TGA handles both solid and liquid samples but is particularly useful for composite materials with multiple components.
• DSC is ideal for pure compounds and materials with distinct thermal transitions, such as polymers or pharmaceutical solids.

3. Analytical Sensitivity

The sensitivity requirements of your analysis will influence your choice. TGA and DSC both provide high sensitivity, but they excel at detecting different types of changes within your sample.

• TGA excels at detecting mass changes as low as micrograms.
• DSC is highly sensitive to thermal events and small energy changes.

4. Complementary Techniques

In many cases, the most comprehensive understanding of a material comes from combining both TGA and DSC data. These techniques provide complementary insights, especially when paired with advanced detection methods.

• Many laboratories use TGA and DSC together to obtain a comprehensive thermal profile.
• TGA-FTIR or TGA-MS can identify gases evolved during decomposition, while DSC offers precise enthalpy and transition temperature data.

TGA and DSC in Multi-Technique Thermal Analysis

While TGA and DSC are powerful individually, their combination provides richer data and a more comprehensive understanding of how materials respond to temperature changes. When used together, these techniques deliver complementary insights into both mass changes and thermal transitions, allowing for deeper characterization.

For example, in polymer characterization, TGA can confirm thermal stability, providing information about degradation temperatures, moisture content, and residual fillers, while DSC tracks phase transitions such as melting, crystallization, and curing. This dual approach helps scientists understand both the chemical composition and physical transformations of materials under thermal stress.

In quality control processes, using both techniques together ensures that both material composition integrity and performance attributes are maintained. This holistic thermal profile is essential in developing materials with optimized properties for pharmaceuticals, polymers, food products, and advanced materials used in energy and environmental applications.

Final Thoughts: TGA and DSC in Thermal Analysis

Both Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA) and Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) offer valuable insights into material properties, but they serve distinct and complementary purposes in thermal analysis. TGA provides a direct assessment of thermal stability and composition by measuring weight changes under controlled temperature conditions, making it ideal for detecting moisture loss, decomposition events, and residual content in complex materials. DSC, on the other hand, focuses on capturing heat flow associated with phase transitions such as melting, crystallization, and glass transitions, offering essential data on the thermal behavior and structural changes within a sample.

Understanding the strengths and limitations of each technique allows laboratories to select the most appropriate method depending on their analytical goals, sample type, and industry requirements. In many cases, combining TGA and DSC in a complementary workflow provides a more complete picture of a material’s thermal profile, supporting robust product development, quality assurance, and regulatory compliance efforts.

• Choose TGA for compositional analysis, thermal stability, and degradation studies.
• Choose DSC for phase transitions, melting points, and heat flow events.

By leveraging TGA and DSC together, labs gain a comprehensive understanding of how materials respond to heat—a critical factor for product development, quality control, and regulatory compliance.

This content includes text that has been generated with the assistance of AI. Lab Manager’s AI policy can be found here.